Skip to content
Snippets Groups Projects
Commit 6a4bfcd6 authored by Liang-Chi Hsieh's avatar Liang-Chi Hsieh Committed by Michael Armbrust
Browse files

[SPARK-13658][SQL] BooleanSimplification rule is slow with large boolean expressions

JIRA: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/SPARK-13658

## What changes were proposed in this pull request?

Quoted from JIRA description: When run TPCDS Q3 [1] with lots predicates to filter out the partitions, the optimizer rule BooleanSimplification take about 2 seconds (it use lots of sematicsEqual, which require copy the whole tree).

It will great if we could speedup it.

[1] https://github.com/cloudera/impala-tpcds-kit/blob/master/queries/q3.sql

How to speed up it:

When we ask the canonicalized expression in `Expression`, it calls `Canonicalize.execute` on itself. `Canonicalize.execute` basically transforms up all expressions included in this expression. However, we don't keep the canonicalized versions for these children expressions. So in next time we ask the canonicalized expressions for the children expressions (e.g., `BooleanSimplification`), we will rerun `Canonicalize.execute` on each of them. It wastes much time.

By forcing the children expressions to get and keep their canonicalized versions first, we can avoid re-canonicalize these expressions.

I simply benchmark it with an expression which is part of the where clause in TPCDS Q3:

    val testRelation = LocalRelation('ss_sold_date_sk.int, 'd_moy.int, 'i_manufact_id.int, 'ss_item_sk.string, 'i_item_sk.string, 'd_date_sk.int)

    val input = ('d_date_sk === 'ss_sold_date_sk) && ('ss_item_sk === 'i_item_sk) && ('i_manufact_id === 436) && ('d_moy === 12) && (('ss_sold_date_sk > 2415355 && 'ss_sold_date_sk < 2415385) || ('ss_sold_date_sk > 2415720 && 'ss_sold_date_sk < 2415750) || ('ss_sold_date_sk > 2416085 && 'ss_sold_date_sk < 2416115) || ('ss_sold_date_sk > 2416450 && 'ss_sold_date_sk < 2416480) || ('ss_sold_date_sk > 2416816 && 'ss_sold_date_sk < 2416846) || ('ss_sold_date_sk > 2417181 && 'ss_sold_date_sk < 2417211) || ('ss_sold_date_sk > 2417546 && 'ss_sold_date_sk < 2417576) || ('ss_sold_date_sk > 2417911 && 'ss_sold_date_sk < 2417941) || ('ss_sold_date_sk > 2418277 && 'ss_sold_date_sk < 2418307) || ('ss_sold_date_sk > 2418642 && 'ss_sold_date_sk < 2418672) || ('ss_sold_date_sk > 2419007 && 'ss_sold_date_sk < 2419037) || ('ss_sold_date_sk > 2419372 && 'ss_sold_date_sk < 2419402) || ('ss_sold_date_sk > 2419738 && 'ss_sold_date_sk < 2419768) || ('ss_sold_date_sk > 2420103 && 'ss_sold_date_sk < 2420133) || ('ss_sold_date_sk > 2420468 && 'ss_sold_date_sk < 2420498) || ('ss_sold_date_sk > 2420833 && 'ss_sold_date_sk < 2420863) || ('ss_sold_date_sk > 2421199 && 'ss_sold_date_sk < 2421229) || ('ss_sold_date_sk > 2421564 && 'ss_sold_date_sk < 2421594) || ('ss_sold_date_sk > 2421929 && 'ss_sold_date_sk < 2421959) || ('ss_sold_date_sk > 2422294 && 'ss_sold_date_sk < 2422324) || ('ss_sold_date_sk > 2422660 && 'ss_sold_date_sk < 2422690) || ('ss_sold_date_sk > 2423025 && 'ss_sold_date_sk < 2423055) || ('ss_sold_date_sk > 2423390 && 'ss_sold_date_sk < 2423420) || ('ss_sold_date_sk > 2423755 && 'ss_sold_date_sk < 2423785) || ('ss_sold_date_sk > 2424121 && 'ss_sold_date_sk < 2424151) || ('ss_sold_date_sk > 2424486 && 'ss_sold_date_sk < 2424516) || ('ss_sold_date_sk > 2424851 && 'ss_sold_date_sk < 2424881) || ('ss_sold_date_sk > 2425216 && 'ss_sold_date_sk < 2425246) || ('ss_sold_date_sk > 2425582 && 'ss_sold_date_sk < 2425612) || ('ss_sold_date_sk > 2425947 && 'ss_sold_date_sk < 2425977) || ('ss_sold_date_sk > 2426312 && 'ss_sold_date_sk < 2426342) || ('ss_sold_date_sk > 2426677 && 'ss_sold_date_sk < 2426707) || ('ss_sold_date_sk > 2427043 && 'ss_sold_date_sk < 2427073) || ('ss_sold_date_sk > 2427408 && 'ss_sold_date_sk < 2427438) || ('ss_sold_date_sk > 2427773 && 'ss_sold_date_sk < 2427803) || ('ss_sold_date_sk > 2428138 && 'ss_sold_date_sk < 2428168) || ('ss_sold_date_sk > 2428504 && 'ss_sold_date_sk < 2428534) || ('ss_sold_date_sk > 2428869 && 'ss_sold_date_sk < 2428899) || ('ss_sold_date_sk > 2429234 && 'ss_sold_date_sk < 2429264) || ('ss_sold_date_sk > 2429599 && 'ss_sold_date_sk < 2429629) || ('ss_sold_date_sk > 2429965 && 'ss_sold_date_sk < 2429995) || ('ss_sold_date_sk > 2430330 && 'ss_sold_date_sk < 2430360) || ('ss_sold_date_sk > 2430695 && 'ss_sold_date_sk < 2430725) || ('ss_sold_date_sk > 2431060 && 'ss_sold_date_sk < 2431090) || ('ss_sold_date_sk > 2431426 && 'ss_sold_date_sk < 2431456) || ('ss_sold_date_sk > 2431791 && 'ss_sold_date_sk < 2431821) || ('ss_sold_date_sk > 2432156 && 'ss_sold_date_sk < 2432186) || ('ss_sold_date_sk > 2432521 && 'ss_sold_date_sk < 2432551) || ('ss_sold_date_sk > 2432887 && 'ss_sold_date_sk < 2432917) || ('ss_sold_date_sk > 2433252 && 'ss_sold_date_sk < 2433282) || ('ss_sold_date_sk > 2433617 && 'ss_sold_date_sk < 2433647) || ('ss_sold_date_sk > 2433982 && 'ss_sold_date_sk < 2434012) || ('ss_sold_date_sk > 2434348 && 'ss_sold_date_sk < 2434378) || ('ss_sold_date_sk > 2434713 && 'ss_sold_date_sk < 2434743)))

    val plan = testRelation.where(input).analyze
    val actual = Optimize.execute(plan)

With this patch:

    352 milliseconds
    346 milliseconds
    340 milliseconds

Without this patch:

    585 milliseconds
    880 milliseconds
    677 milliseconds

## How was this patch tested?

Existing tests should pass.

Author: Liang-Chi Hsieh <simonh@tw.ibm.com>
Author: Liang-Chi Hsieh <viirya@gmail.com>

Closes #11647 from viirya/improve-expr-canonicalize.
parent 63f642ae
No related branches found
No related tags found
No related merge requests found
Loading
0% Loading or .
You are about to add 0 people to the discussion. Proceed with caution.
Finish editing this message first!
Please register or to comment